Global Healthcare Systems

March 21, 2022
Download Policy Brief
Written By:

Executive Summary

The United States has a mixed healthcare system with mostly private health insurers and a public healthcare option. The U.S. is one of several countries across the world with such a system, while some other countries provide a single-payer, fully public healthcare system, and others rely on solely private healthcare. In this brief, we examine the logistics of each healthcare system, as well as their benefits and drawbacks.

Introduction

Unlike most countries, the United States does not offer free or universal healthcare for its citizens. Instead, our healthcare system is made up of public and private insurers and healthcare providers, some of which support our welfare programs, namely Medicare and Medicaid. These programs aim to support the elderly, disabled, and poor, and thus the vast majority of Americans get their health insurance elsewhere - usually through their employers. This system has been under scrutiny since its creation, as many believe this system has led to increasing disparities in health outcomes for low-income and minority groups. 

Pointed Summary

  • The health-care system in the United States is a mix of public and private insurers, as well as for-profit and nonprofit health-care providers.
  • The Social Security Act of 1965 established the first public insurance systems, Medicare and Medicaid, and others followed.
  • Medicare ensures that all people over the age of 65 have access to health care. Medicaid was the first program to give states the option of receiving federal matching funds for providing health care to low-income families, the blind, and people with disabilities.
  • The Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) is a government-run health insurance program, established in 1997 as a public, state-run program for low-income children whose families earn too much to qualify for Medicaid yet are unlikely to be able to afford private insurance. 
  • The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, or ACA, was passed in 2010, marking the most significant increase of the government's role in financing and regulating health care to date. 
  • Healthcare systems vary across the world, with some countries implementing a fully public universal healthcare system and others implementing a fully private healthcare system. There are also several other countries with a mixed system similar to the US.

Medicaid + CHIP

Medicaid was signed into law in 1965 alongside Medicare, and has been insuring low income Americans ever since. Although the federal government establishes certain parameters for Medicaid, administration is largely up to states - many of which have chosen to participate in Medicaid expansions over the years. In order to receive federal funding, states must cover certain “mandatory” populations:

  • children under 18 in families with income at or below 138% (1.38x the federal poverty income threshold) of the federal poverty line 
  •  pregnant individuals who have an income at or below 138% of the poverty line;
  • low-income parents or caretakers
  • seniors and disabled individuals who receive cash assistance through the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program.

States also have the option to expand their programs to include additional vulnerable populations. 

Medicaid is a counter-cyclical program, meaning its enrollment expands during recessions to insure those who lose their employer sponsored healthcare. Anyone who meets the requirements for Medicaid is entitled to apply for benefits.

The Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) is a program that was signed into law in 1997 with the purpose of insuring children of low-income families whose income is above the 138% requirement, but too low to afford private care. This is a separate program in some states, and an expansion of Medicaid in others. 

Medicare 

Medicare is another federal insurance program offered by the U.S. for individuals 65 and over and certain younger disabled individuals. Medicare is made up of four parts: A, B, C and D. 

Part A covers hospital stays, hospice care, and in some cases, skilled nursing outpatient care. Part B covers most doctor and outpatient services - diagnostic screenings, doctors visits, etc. Individuals will have some coinsurance payments under part B. Medicare part C is Medicare Advantage, a mixed public/private option that will be discussed later. Lastly, part D covers prescription drugs, but can only be purchased through a private provider (or through Medicare Advantage). 

There are two main ways to get Medicare coverage: 

  • Original Medicare: Includes both Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance). Individuals have a deductible, paid at the beginning of the year, and some coinsurance for certain procedures.
  • Medicare Advantage: Medicare Advantage is a Medicare-approved plan from a private insurance company. These insurance plans have yearly contracts with Medicare and must follow certain coverage rules, but may offer additional benefits such as vision, dental, and hearing services. These plans usually include Medicare Part D - which offers coverage for prescription drugs. 

Healthcare Disparities

In the current US health system, there exists disparities in individuals who receive the treatment that they need. Oftentimes, some individuals do not get the health treatment that they require due to their inability to pay for health insurance or because of inequities based on location. The US Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion suggests that efforts like lowering costs, improving insurance coverage, and increasing the use of telehealth services can reduce current inequities in the American healthcare system.

Policy Analysis

Problem

Tried Policy 

As our healthcare system is complex and deeply connected to our economy, it has proven difficult to instigate structural change to address its issues. Thus, attempts at meaningful change are often suggestions or campaigns by nonprofits and NGOs. 

A partnership between the CDC, the CDC foundation, the Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion (ODPHP), and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) has resulted in the Law and Policy Project. This project aims to increase the health of our nation’s communities by sharing information about law and policy interventions - and through this work hopes to show how law and policy can be useful tools to increase healthcare access. 

In addition, the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) declared their 2021 policy priorities, which are aimed at providing quality care for the nation’s most vulnerable populations, and ensuring the well-being of their communities. These policy priorities include driving new discoveries and workforce training and education programs. 

Nonpartisan Reasoning

Opinions vary in the U.S. populace regarding the current mixed healthcare system. Two-thirds of Americans would prefer a Canadian-style, single-payer healthcare system with universal coverage, and three-fifths of doctors support the same. The Canadian healthcare system is a decentralized, universal, publicly funded system known as Canadian Medicare. Rather than delegating all logistics to the federal government, each Canadian province has its own insurance plan, and each province receives federal cash assistance depending on provincial population. Additionally, a majority (two-thirds) of Canadians still have private health insurance.

Under a primarily privatized healthcare system like the US, one advantage is that patients are able to choose their own doctor and preferred medical facility, providing more flexibility for patients. There are also often shorter wait times for patients because the medical facility is less busy, especially for surgeries that are not life-threatening. Additionally, the medical facilities are often of higher quality because private facilities are often better maintained and better funded.

On the other hand, privatized healthcare also has its fair share of drawbacks, especially in cost. American citizens pay much more money for private healthcare coverage than what would be required in a public healthcare system. In the U.S., most citizens pay around $200 monthly premiums on top of a copay and deductible, whereas the average monthly cost for citizens in a public healthcare system is $100 with no copay or deductibles. Another criticism of private healthcare is the inequity that it can create. Power lies with the insurance companies to decide who insurance covers;whereas in a public system, all citizens are treated equally, regardless of their ability to pay. Finally, private health insurance rarely covers all medical services, as patients must choose the health insurance quote that best suits their needs. This can result in gaps in access that force patients into exorbitant treatment costs or to waive treatment.

Policy Options

While the United States implements a combination of public and private healthcare with no universal healthcare option, other countries like Norway, Japan, the United Kingdom, Kuwait, Sweden, Canada, Bahrain, Denmark, and others implement a single-payer healthcare system. Other countries like Israel, Liechtenstein, the Netherlands, and Switzerland have a universal private health insurance system, in which private insurance is mandatory for citizens. There also exists a fair share of countries with a healthcare system similar to the US with non-universal insurance, in which some citizens have private health insurance, some are eligible for public insurance, and some are uninsured. These countries include Bangladesh, Burundi, Congo, Egypt, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Jordan, Kenya, Nigeria, and Paraguay.

Conclusion

In the U.S., healthcare is often a heated topic of discussion. The current system incorporates aspects of both a system reliant solely on private health insurance companies and a public system similar to that of Canada and the Scandinavian countries. There exists advantages on both sides of the spectrum, with the advantages of a private healthcare system lying in its increased flexibility for patients and improved facilities and advantages of a public healthcare system lying in its lower costs and improved equity. Ultimately, the diversity of global healthcare systems is a testament to the nuance of the subject.

Author Information

Stephanie Wang
Public Health Policy Lead

Stephanie is a high school senior, researcher, and Public Health Policy Lead. She is a passionate advocate of public health literacy and the author of Epidemiology Unmasked: An Introduction to Epidemiology in Public Health. In particular, Stephanie is interested in domestic, health, and educational policy and has conducted research on vaccine distribution, Alzheimer's disease, and public health education.

Samantha Overhauser
Public Health Policy Lead

Samantha is a college student in the final year of a BBA in economics. She serves as a Public Health Policy Brief Lead for YIP, as well as serving on the student union board at Baylor University. She is currently conducting research on health equity and safety net policy and intends to pursue a Master’s in Public Health.

Adrienne Yue

Hi, my name is Adrienne and I'm a 16 year old from the Bay Area! I'm passionate about healthcare, public policy, and social medicine. I identify as a liberal and am excited to be a part of YIP!

Jack Samet

Jack Samet is a high school junior and conservative Democrat living in Los Angeles, California who focuses on examining domestic and social policy. In his spare time, he enjoys writing, watching movies, debating contentious societal issues, and listening to classic rock and folk.

Dan Siddiqui

Dan Siddiqui is a political activist and public speaker in his senior year of high school. He hosts the Youth In Policy podcast which has featured guests such as Noam Chomsky, Jo Jorgensen, and Howie Hawkins. In addition, he’s the political lead for the Silicon Valley chapter of the Sunrise Movement where he’s organized several protests in the bay area.

Hiba Khan

Hiba is a 17-year-old high school senior from Southern Maryland. She holds a vested passion for political science and public policy which has been reflected through her involvement on several state-level leadership organizations. In her free time, she indulges in video games, reading, and writing. After high school, Hiba hopes to pursue a career in law or foreign policy.

Jane Vu

Jane Vu is currently a student from New Jersey who has a passion in economics and foreign affairs. She has worked closely with many peers in her area and around the world to conduct research proposals! In her free time, she likes to bake, read, and ride her bike!

Read More!

Looking for more? Subscribe to our Policy Brief Newsletter!

Get our latest policy briefs delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.